Contrasting digital and traditional art, with circuitry and paint brushes against a sunset wave backdrop.

The Argument for Authenticity: Why Some Artists Reject AI Art on Instagram

In the ever-evolving landscape of art, a new tempest brews, pitting the Old Guard against the New, the Traditionalists against the Technophiles. At the heart of this cultural maelstrom is AI Art – the futuristic offspring of algorithms and aesthetics. Its canvas? The digital galleries of Instagram, where it provokes and perplexes in equal measure.

But here’s the rub: not all are enamored with this silicon muse. A cohort of artists, fiercely loyal to the brush and canvas, the chisel and stone, view AI art with a mix of skepticism and disdain. And their argument? Authenticity.

The Aura of the Handmade

Walter Benjamin, in his prescient 1935 essay "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction," spoke of the 'aura' of art – an ineffable quality tied to its unique existence in time and space. For traditional artists, this aura is sacrosanct, a holy grail of authenticity that AI, with its algorithmic genesis, cannot hope to capture.

These artists argue that art is an extension of the human experience, a tangible testament to the artist's skill, emotion, and vision. It's about the physical touch, the brush strokes that carry the weight of emotion, the sculptor's chisel marks that tell a story of labor and love. This tactile, visceral connection is absent in AI art, they say, rendering it soulless, a ghost in the machine.

The Dance of Creativity

Surreal art with a dancer among cosmic swirls, celestial bodies, and esoteric symbols, depicting harmony between universe and movement


Traditional artists argue that this process is deeply personal, an intimate journey that AI cannot undertake. For them, art is not just the end product but the journey itself – the struggle, the eureka moments, the happy accidents.

AI, on the other hand, operates on datasets and algorithms. It's a process devoid of personal history, of sleepless nights spent wrestling with a concept, of the joy in finally "getting it right." It’s this human journey of creation that artists feel AI art cannot replicate, making it a hollow imitation at best.

The Specter of Uniformity V Authenticity

Another fear lurking in the hearts of traditional artists is the specter of uniformity. They argue that AI art, fed by existing art, is inherently derivative. It's a mirror reflecting a mirror, infinitely regurgitating and remixing the old, with little room for true innovation.

Art, in its most celebrated form, is about pushing boundaries, breaking norms, and challenging perceptions. It's about the unique voice of the artist coming through in their work. Traditionalists argue that AI, in its current form, lacks this ability to truly innovate, to bring something wholly new and groundbreaking to the table.

The Ethics of Artistic Creation

There’s also an ethical dimension to this debate. The use of AI in art raises questions about authorship and originality. When an AI creates art, who is the artist? The programmer? The AI itself? This ambiguity troubles those who see art as a deeply personal expression.

Moreover, there’s the issue of data sourcing. AI systems are trained on vast datasets, often scraped from the internet, including works of countless unnamed artists. This raises concerns about consent and credit – issues that are fundamental to the ethos of artistic creation.

The Counterargument: Evolution of Art

On the flip side, proponents of AI art argue that art has always evolved with technology. From the invention of oil paints to the camera, each new technology has expanded the horizons of what art can be. They see AI as just another tool in the artist's kit, one that can push the boundaries of creativity in unprecedented ways.

Embracing the New, Respecting the Old

As we stand at this crossroads, the question isn't whether AI art will find its place in the annals of art history – it most certainly will. The real question is how we can reconcile this new form with traditional art. The answer lies in respect and understanding – respecting the new possibilities AI art brings while understanding and honoring the time-honored traditions of the art world.

As we navigate this brave new world, let's remember that art, in all its forms, is a reflection of our humanity. Whether born from a brush or a byte, it speaks to our endless quest for expression and connection. And in this quest, there is room for both the human hand and the algorithmic mind.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.